Fans of the Dodgers can likely identify with Tanner Scott’s insights regarding his challenges during the 2025 season. While some may view Scott as a disappointment for the Los Angeles Dodgers, particularly given the weight of his four-year, $72 million contract, he offers a compelling explanation for his struggles. In a recent article by Dylan Hernandez from The New York Post, Scott candidly discussed the overwhelming pressure that came with his hefty deal.
Scott shared with Hernandez that his inaugural season with the Dodgers was mentally taxing, saying, "It was mentally exhausting." This admission sets the stage for understanding how expectations can significantly impact an athlete's performance.
As Scott explained, the intense pressure to justify his contract led him to adjust his pitching strategy. He began to throw more pitches within the strike zone than usual, which unfortunately resulted in poor outcomes on the field. His statistics reflected this shift, culminating in a disappointing 4.74 ERA and nine blown saves. These struggles not only jeopardized his place in manager Dave Roberts' playoff plans but also contributed to injuries that sidelined him—first with elbow inflammation and later due to an abscess that required surgery.
As Scott faced these physical and mental hurdles, his status as the third-highest paid reliever in baseball added to his anxiety. The fear of damaging his reputation and letting down the Dodgers surely weighed heavily on him. Compounding this issue was the critical assessment from media outlets; The Athletic even ranked Scott's contract as the 10th worst in Major League Baseball, making it hard for him to escape the scrutiny.
However, Scott's experiences might resonate with many Dodgers fans who understand what it's like to grapple with overwhelming expectations and not meet them—this shared experience could foster empathy towards him. After all, we’ve all faced moments in our lives where we feel the pressure to succeed and ultimately falter. By bravely sharing his story, Scott may garner support from fans who appreciate his vulnerability, especially since he has a lot to prove after last season.
Inside the Dodgers organization, Scott still has allies. General Manager Brandon Gomes and President of Baseball Operations Andrew Friedman have both publicly expressed confidence in his potential for a comeback in the 2026 season. However, their support might feel somewhat hollow, especially in light of the Dodgers’ decision to sign Edwin Díaz for $69 million, a move seemingly prompted by Scott’s previous shortcomings.
While the acquisition of Díaz wasn't intended to directly assist Scott, it inadvertently alleviates some of the pressure he faced. With a proven closer like Díaz now part of the bullpen, Scott might find the relief he needs to regain his confidence and excel. The Dodgers' bullpen has seen a range of unpredictable performances over the past year, proving that anything can happen. For example, Roki Sasaki's rookie season was marked by unexpected twists, concluding with him thriving in a closer role after a rocky start.
In the grand scheme, the chance for Tanner Scott to turn things around is very much alive, and the pressures that previously hindered him have been lifted. As we watch the next chapter unfold, one has to wonder: Can Scott break free from the shackles of expectation and reclaim his spot as a reliable pitcher? What do you think—can he rise to the occasion, or will those past struggles continue to haunt him? Feel free to share your thoughts in the comments!
