The MLB Pipeline Podcast just dropped a bombshell, revealing their early predictions for the 2026 Rookie of the Year race! But are these picks set in stone? Let's dive in and explore the experts' choices.
Jim Callis and Jonathan Mayo, the baseball gurus, shared their hypothetical ballots, and it's fascinating to see their foresight in action. In 2022, they accurately foresaw Gunnar Henderson and Corbin Carroll's rise to glory. But fast forward to 2024, and their mock draft didn't include Paul Skenes until Round 4, and Luis Gil's potential was overlooked.
So, who's on their radar for 2026? Let's find out:
National League:
- Callis' Pick: JJ Wetherholt, SS (STL No. 1 / MLB No. 5) - A potential superstar in the making, Wetherholt's talent is undeniable. Despite Masyn Winn's presence at shortstop, Callis envisions Wetherholt's versatility, seeing him at third or second base. With impressive stats in Triple-A, he's a player to watch, even if he didn't get the hype he deserved.
Mayo's Take: Bubba Chandler, RHP (PIT No. 2 / MLB No. 14) - Chandler's potential is evident, and Mayo believes he'll be a rotation regular. His recent performances showcase his potential, but command issues in Triple-A could be a concern. Learning from Paul Skenes might be the key to his success.
- Callis' Choice: Owen Caissie, OF (CHC No. 1 / MLB No. 47) - Caissie's a favorite of Callis, known for his consistent production despite his youth. With 41 homers in Triple-A over two seasons, he's not just a power hitter but also an underrated athlete. Callis predicts a right-field battle between Caissie and Kevin Alcántara.
Mayo's Selection: Nolan McLean, RHP (NYM No. 1 / MLB No. 11) - McLean's ceiling as a pitcher is high, according to Mayo. His impressive 2024 season in New York hints at untapped potential, and with more experience, he could be a force to be reckoned with.
- Mayo's Pick: Sal Stewart, 3B/2B (CIN No. 1 / MLB No. 31) - Mayo's confidence in Stewart's bat is evident. With a stellar OPS in the Minors, Stewart's hitting prowess is undeniable. His defensive versatility adds to his appeal, making him a strong contender.
Callis' Take: McLean - Callis admits his preference for position players for the ROY award, but he can't ignore McLean's dominance for the Mets. He believes McLean's talent surpasses initial expectations, earning him the nickname "Cowboy Ohtani."
American League:
- Callis' Pick: Samuel Basallo, C (BAL No. 1 / MLB No. 7) - Basallo's offensive prowess is undeniable, combining power and average at a young age. Despite a low batting average in his debut, his home run numbers are promising. Callis predicts a lineup role for Basallo, but the specifics remain unclear.
Mayo's Agreement: Basallo - Mayo echoes Callis' sentiments, emphasizing Basallo's hitting abilities. He envisions Basallo in a flexible role, playing first base, DH, and catching, ensuring he gets ample at-bats.
- Callis' Choice: Kevin McGonigle, SS (DET No. 1 / MLB No. 2) - Callis believes in McGonigle's bat, calling him the best pure hitter in the Minors. Despite limited games above High-A, Callis thinks Detroit's desire to win could fast-track McGonigle's debut.
Mayo's Selection: Trey Yesavage, RHP (TOR No. 1 / MLB No. 26) - Yesavage's talent is undeniable, and Mayo believes he'll be a long-term big-league starter. His impressive postseason performance speaks for itself, but Mayo also acknowledges the unpredictability of such breakouts.
- Mayo's Pick: McGonigle - Mayo acknowledges McGonigle's potential but questions his limited experience above A-ball. His defensive position is also a topic of discussion, with the Tigers exploring options.
Callis' Take: Yesavage - Callis highlights Yesavage's remarkable postseason performance, almost leading the Blue Jays to a World Series win. His stuff and competitiveness make him a lock for the rotation, and a promising rookie season awaits.
But here's where it gets controversial: Will these predictions hold up, or will we see surprise contenders emerge? The beauty of baseball is its unpredictability. What do you think? Are these experts on the right track, or do you have other players in mind? Share your thoughts and let's spark a lively discussion about the future stars of MLB!
